Crescent and the Star Review and GIVE-AWAY

— 42 Comments


See who won a copy of Crescent and Star: Turkey Between Two Worlds by Stephen Kinzer. Click here.
And be sure to read my interview with Mr. Kinzer- click here.

Crescent and star

“Lies, Lies!!!”

I barely recognized the distorted face spewing venom at me.

A minute earlier a group of us were sitting in a room in the Business Admin building on the Bilkent University campus working on a group project.

I took advantage of a pause in our work to ask some questions about the Armenians in eastern Turkey after WWI. I gave no details or even hints about what I was thinking, but my classmate, who had been so friendly a minute before, went into a fiery rage.

I honestly feared for my safety. This was my introduction to “Topics Not To Be Discussed in Turkey”.I had been reading Kinzer’s excellent work and wanted to ask my classmates some questions about what I was learning. Bad idea. So you do not make the same mistake, I am here to tell you, “Do not discuss Cyprus, Armenians, Greece, or Kurds with Turkish friends unless you know them well and are careful in bringing up the topic.”

Regardless, I highly recommend Stephen Kinzer’s Crescent and Star: Turkey Between Two Worlds. Kinzer, the NYT correspondent in Istanbul for four years in the late 90′s, clearly loves Turkey and wants to see it reach its potential. He is fearful that it will be like those athletes who should be one of the best in their sport but for various reasons never seem to get there. He skillfully mixes culture, politics, history, and day-to-day life in his very readable prose.

Between each chapter he includes little anecdotal stories, named “meze”s (appetizers), that introduce the concept of the coming chapter in a memorable way. He covers Ataturk, Raki and the meyhane culture, the deep state, the aforementioned Armenian issue, Turkish Islam, the Kurds from the viewpoint of a much maligned Kurdish village, human rights abuses and freedom, the Turkish army, the significance of the Turks who fought in the Korean War, the 1999 earthquake, relations with Greece, the banned author Nazim Hikmet, and much more. In the process he takes his readers on a journey from the Aegean Sea to Lake Van, from the Black Sea to the Med and many places in between.

Read the book, learn from Kinzer’s experience, and ask questions, but be careful!

Are you interested in other Turkey-related books? Check these out:
The New Turkey: The Quiet Revolution on the Edge of Europe by Chris Morris
The Visitor: A Stranger, A Message, A Clash of Cultures by Peter Pikkert
Cappadocia Travel Guide by Oberheu & Wadenpohl
Turkish Alevis Today by John Shindeldecker
The White Castle by Orhan Pamuk
Crescent and Star by Stephen Kinzer
Ataturk: The Biography of the Founder of Modern Turkey by Andrew Mango
The Ottoman Centuries: The Rise and Fall of the Turkish Empire by Lord Kinross
A Fez of the Heart: Travels around Turkey in Search of a Hat By Jeremy Seal
29 Books Related to Turkey: A Reading List


Did you enjoy this post? If so, here’s what you can do. Please share this post with your friends by clicking on one of the buttons below or to the side. Also, you may want to subscribe to these posts. Click here and follow the instructions. One of my goals is to help people who will visit Cappadocia. This is your way to help me meet this goal. Thank you, I am grateful.

Duke Dillard moved to Turkey with his wife and 6 children in 2007. He got an MBA at Bilkent University in Ankara, where they had their 7th child. After 4 years in Ankara the whole family moved to Cappadocia, and this blog was born. We love Cappadocia and Cappadocians and want to help visitors make the most of their time here. You can connect with Duke on Facebook, follow him on Twitter, and/or link circles on Google+. Click here to read more about Duke and his family.


Disclosure of Material Connection: Most of the links in the post above are “affiliate links.” This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will add value to my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the US Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

  • Ben

    Even if I’m nowhere near discussing any of those hot potatoes with any Turk, at least not in turkish, I would love to get a broad knowledge and perspective in the issues should I ever be in a position to discuss them. And I’m the first to leave a comment (my second one on this blog!)
    Greetings to you and your family,
    love the blog,

    Ben

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      Dear Ben,
      Thanks for the quick comment. Have you read Kinzer already?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Peter-Murray/718019814 Peter Murray

    Turkey is such a fascinating country. I have so much to learn.

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      Don’t we all! Thanks for commenting, Pete.

  • Aaron

    I don’t have the updated edition as I’ve always respected Kinzer and his interaction with a very complex nation, as well as anyone who has had the chance to interview him!

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      Thanks Aaron. He told me the updated edition is updated for the last 10 years so is definitely worth reading even if you read the first one.

  • Tanibear

    Having lived in Turkey for the past 22 years, you would think that I know everything there is to know about the culture but alas that isnt the case. I love my adoptive country and I enjoy reading other peoples perspectives..if anything it will give me plenty to discuss with my Turkish friends.

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      Yes, it will give plenty to discuss. Congrats on 22 years!

  • JKH

    I am looking forward to reading Kinzer’s book. I will, however, take heed and be careful about some of the hotter topics, when chatting with Turkish citizens. Thanks for the heads-up, Duke!

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      Thanks John. You need to come visit soon so you can have those chats- much like at the MEC in the old days!

  • http://www.everydaylanguagelearner.com Aaron G Myers

    Duke,
    Great blog! Looking forward to continuing to follow the journey. 4 years in Turkey myself.

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      Thanks for the encouragement, Aaron. Let me know when you visit Cappadocia.

  • Cheryl Weaver

    I think that Kinzer writes well about Turkey and I would like to share this book with like minded people.

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      Thanks, Cheryl, I agree that this is a good one to share!

  • vivianljones

    I teach English in Turkey in the summer and I want to know more about the country. I love being there and love the discussions we have with our students!

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      This book definitely brings up some good topics to discuss. That is a great forum because it will be “safe” for people to share in a class in which they know each other and have relationship.

  • http://twitter.com/stephen_dh stephen harris

    It’s always a challenge to get beyond the everyday surface bubble down into the reality of the world view that drives this country…there seems to be so much to learn, and to be honest that’s why I’d be interested in reading this book. If it helps me grasp a little bit more of ‘how people tick’ then it’s done the job well!

  • http://twitter.com/stephen_dh stephen harris

    Any book that helps a foreign ‘guest’ get beyond the surface bubble into the reality of the culture has got to be warmly welcomed. There is so much complexity here and anything that helps me grasp a little bit more of how people *actually* think I will read with enthusiasm!

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      Very true, Stephen, and I think this book hits the target.

  • http://www.worldwidefamilies.org Em

    Turkey is a fascinating country crossing two continents!
    I am seriously considering working there… it would be great to learn more about it!
    (Of course, my interest is a bit biased by the wonderful people I know there!)

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      We would love to have you closer, Emily.

  • http://twitter.com/stephen_dh stephen harris

    Any book that helps get someone beyond the surface bubble of tea, kebabs and warm smiles deeper into the culture of Turkey is warmly welcome. Superficially Turkey is ‘easy to know’ but pressing on through the years and I find out how little I know. If someone has insights to share, I need to read them!

  • Pingback: An Interview with Author Stephen Kinzer | Captivating Cappadocia

  • Pingback: Why Do I Post Book Reviews? | Captivating Cappadocia

  • Pingback: 29 Books to Read If You Are Interested in Turkey | Captivating Cappadocia

  • cdeb

    People have recommended this book to me on a few occasions, and I’ve read bits of it, but not the whole thing. I think I’ve even given it away as a Christmas present. So, it’s high time I got myself a real copy! BTW, I don’t have a Twitter account so can’t post there. I hope I’m still in the draw…

    • http://CaptivatingCappadocia.com Duke Dillard

      Yes, it is okay that you do not have a Twitter account. I have had the same experience with certain books. Thanks for sharing.

  • Pingback: 4 Winners of The White Castle by Orhan Pamuk | Captivating Cappadocia

  • Pingback: A Fez of the Heart by Jeremy Seal REVIEW & GIVEAWAY | Captivating Cappadocia

  • Pingback: Turkish Alevis Today by John Shindeldecker – Review | Captivating Cappadocia

  • Pingback: 5 Winners of The Ottoman Centuries by Lord Kinross - Captivating Cappadocia

  • Pingback: The Ottoman Centuries by Lord Kinross REVIEW & GIVEAWAY - Captivating Cappadocia

  • Pingback: 6 Winners of A Fez of the Heart by Jeremy Seal - Captivating Cappadocia

  • Pingback: 10+ Winners of Kinzer Book - Captivating Cappadocia

  • Pingback: Ataturk by Andrew Mango- Review and Give-away - Captivating Cappadocia

  • Vivian Jones

    I enjoyed reading Crescent and Star because it helped me understand the very complex Turkish history and helped me avoid the hot topics with my Turkish friends.

  • ben

    Great read, well written, very balanced. Very good introduction for anyone interested in understanding Turkey better. Dört Dörtlük! (Ten out of ten)

  • Pingback: Fifty Turkish Folktales of Nasreddin Hodja

  • charles de bueger

    I hadn’t been aware that Kinzer had only been living in Turkey for four years (as Duke says above) – but I expect his job of being an inquisitive journalist helped him get a better handle on Turkey and what drives it better than many of us who have lived here for years. Certainly what he writes matches my own experiences here, and I have also learned quite a few things I never knew from reading his book. It seems he had better connections here than me! Certainly a worthwhile, educational and generally entertaining read.

    • dukedillard

      Thank you Charles for taking the time to share your thoughts. I am glad to hear you enjoyed the book. I learned a lot as well. I was amazed at how much he was able to cover in his time here as well.

  • Em

    I greatly enjoyed reading Crescent and Star, written well and from an interesting perspective. A taste of Turkish culture was combined with the relevance of recent history. In some ways it left me on the edge of my seat, ready to watch and see how the story of the nation continues to unfold.

  • Pingback: 100 Turkish Foods: How Many Have You Tried in Cappadocia?